Couldn't We Just Use AI for This? A Designer's Honest Answer

I recently watched Avedon, the Netflix documentary about Richard Avedon, the legendary photographer behind some of the most iconic portraits of the last century. If you've ever taken an art history class, you know his work. He’s photographed presidents and activists, models and movie stars. And by most accounts, it sounds like he was a genuinely good guy.

I watched most of it in awe. I also spent a good chunk of it insanely jealous, which is a very normal response to watching someone else's genius for two hours.

There's a quote at the end of the documentary that I haven't stopped thinking about:

"What makes a good photographer is not the technique. It's the mind behind the camera." — Richard Avedon

It turns out to be the most succinct answer to the AI debate raging right now.

The question on everyone's mind

If you manage a brand, run a nonprofit or wear the marketing hat on top of six other hats, someone has probably asked you this. Maybe it was a board member looking at the budget. Maybe it was you, staring at a deadline: Couldn't we just use AI to make this?

It's a fair question. The tools are fast, they're cheap and they're right there. When money is tight, "good enough in thirty seconds" sounds tempting.

AI is the camera

Anyone can pick up a camera. Not everyone can be Avedon.

AI works the same way. It's a tool. It can produce something that looks like a logo or reads like a blog post. What it can't do is teach good taste. If you aren't a copywriter, AI won't make your writing suddenly compelling. If you aren't a designer, it won't turn you into one. It simply hands you an average of everything that already exists.

And average is the problem. Average is the thing that blends in that they see right through.

When you hire a designer, you're not just paying for software skills. You're paying for discernment: the judgment to know what fits and what doesn't, and why.

When a client tells me they want something that feels "retro," they're handing me a feeling, not a design. I have to figure out which retro they mean. A 1950s diner and a 1970s album cover are both retro, and they would send completely different messages about your business. "Luxe" could mean a Manhattan hotel lobby or it could mean your grandmother's good china.

You shouldn't have to know the difference. That's my job.

I can do it because it’s what I do. I've spent my whole life paying attention. I notice the details: the hand-painted signage on an old Italian restaurant in South Philly, and the bakers twine on a box of Isgro's pastries.

None of that came from a design software. It came from living, traveling and looking closely. It's the creative rolodex I pull from every time someone says "make it feel like us."

I recently heard a design professor say it perfectly. She said that if she could go back and teach her students anything, she'd skip the software lessons. Anyone can learn the tools. She'd tell them to buy the concert ticket, take the trip and see the film, because that's where the inspiration comes from.

Trends vs. taste

Plenty of design, whether a person or a machine made it, simply copies what's popular right now. It looks fresh for about eighteen months and then it becomes dated. Worse, it makes you look like everyone else in your category.

Good design doesn't start with the trend. It starts with knowing where the trend derived from: the art, architecture, music and history behind it. That's how you borrow the right details and leave the rest. It's also how your brand still feels like you five years from now.

Back to that documentary.

Somewhere between the jealousy and the awe, I landed on something closer to peace. I'll never see the world the way Avedon did. But no machine will ever see it the way I do, either, and the same is true of every good designer you might hire.

That's the whole point. Your brand deserves a mind behind the camera.

Next
Next

Naomi